As a Christian rooted in rural Missouri, I’ve valued the MAGA movement’s promise to champion faith, family, and freedom. Yet, its leading voices—Candace Owens, Tucker Carlson, Steve Bannon, and Marjorie Taylor Greene—have embraced MAGA unbiblical rhetoric that contradicts scripture and sows division. Their recent statements, particularly on U.S.-Israel relations, reveal a pattern of exploiting faith for clicks, subscriptions, and fame, often flirting with antisemitic tropes. For Christians drawn to MAGA’s conservative ideals, it’s time to exercise discernment (1 John 4:1) and ask whether these leaders align with our faith. While their followers include well-meaning believers, their unbiblical rhetoric demands we reconsider their influence and, if necessary, distance ourselves from a movement prioritizing grift over gospel.
The Unbiblical Rhetoric of MAGA Leaders
Scripture calls Christians to love, truth, and humility (John 13:34–35, Ephesians 4:15). Yet, the MAGA unbiblical rhetoric of Owens, Carlson, Bannon, and Greene distorts faith. Candace Owens has framed her anti-Israel stance in ways that twist theology. In a post on X, she claimed:
They tried to redefine antisemitism, criminalize criticism of Israel on college campuses, and most crucially, seed the idea that the declaration of Christ as our King amounted to hatred against Jews.
This misrepresents Romans 11:1–2, which affirms God’s covenant with Israel, by pitting Christ’s lordship against it, violating Colossians 3:8’s call to avoid slander. Critics on X called this “divisive,” arguing it undermines biblical unity.
Marjorie Taylor Greene similarly misuses faith. In a social media post, she wrote:
Mark Levin needs to meet my friend Jesus… who will return one day and those that did not recognize him will mourn.
This jab at a Jewish commentator distorts Revelation 1:7, implying divine judgment against Israel supporters, and risks religious hostility, contradicting Matthew 7:1’s warning against judgmental condemnation. X users labeled it “unchristian.”
Tucker Carlson questions biblical support for U.S.-Israel policy, as seen in a clash with Senator Ted Cruz, citing Genesis in a way that sows confusion. Though not overtly false, his framing lacks Psalm 119:125’s discernment. Steve Bannon’s claim that Israel is a “protectorate” exploiting America ignores Micah 6:8’s call for justice, prioritizing nationalism over scripture.
Antisemitic Tropes: A Dangerous Undercurrent
The MAGA unbiblical rhetoric of these figures often flirts with antisemitic tropes. Owens’ post alleging U.S. foreign policy is “dictated by Israel” and politicians are “bought” echoes conspiracies like the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. Her claim that pro-Israel groups paid pastors “millions” to silence her and Carlson doubles down on this trope. X users criticized her for “peddling hate.”
Greene’s post linking JFK’s assassination to Israel’s nuclear program revives a baseless antisemitic conspiracy, condemned as “dangerous nonsense.” Her “neocon warmongers” rhetoric codes pro-Israel figures as elites, risking stereotypes. Carlson’s naming of “warmongers” like Miriam Adelson implies pro-Israel influence, called “reckless” on X. Bannon’s “protectorate” claim suggests disloyalty, a classic antisemitic framing. These violate Exodus 20:16’s command against false witness, alienating Christians who value Israel’s biblical role (Genesis 12:3).
Grift Over Gospel: Profiting from Provocation
These leaders’ MAGA unbiblical rhetoric often serves profit, not faith. Owens’ post calling Gaza a “concentration camp” with “Goebbels levels of propaganda” garnered millions of views, boosting her YouTube subscriptions. Her feud with Laura Loomer over MAGA loyalty reveals a chase for “clout.” Carlson’s warning that war could “end Trump’s presidency” went viral, monetizing controversy on his platforms.
Bannon’s WarRoom thrives on claims like war “destroying MAGA forever,” keeping listeners hooked for ad revenue. Greene’s post, “Anyone slobbering for the U.S. to become fully involved in the Israel/Iran war is not America First/MAGA,” fuels her profile, building on past conspiracies like Jewish space lasers. These figures dominate charts by flooding platforms with provocative content, betraying 2 Peter 2:3’s warning against exploitation.
Three Ways MAGA Leaders Stray from Scripture
To understand why Christians should reconsider these voices, consider:
- Twisting Faith: Owens and Greene misuse scripture to attack opponents, ignoring Ephesians 4:29’s call for edifying words.
- Fueling Division: Their antisemitic tropes, like alleging Israeli control, contradict John 17:21’s call for unity.
- Prioritizing Profit: Their viral posts prioritize clicks over truth, violating 1 Timothy 6:10’s warning against loving money.
A Call to Christians: Reclaim Biblical Values
For Christians drawn to MAGA, the unbiblical rhetoric of these leaders is a wake-up call. Their claims—calling Israel a “terrorist state” or implying neocons control Trump—stray from Philippians 4:8’s focus on what is true. X users have called them “divisive,” urging believers to reject their influence.
This isn’t about abandoning conservative values. Like many in rural Missouri, I share concerns about cultural decline and government overreach, rooted in faith. But we need leaders who embody Christ’s love, not controversy. If MAGA continues elevating grifters, we must reconsider our allegiance—not to reject our principles, but to reclaim them. Share your thoughts on X about MAGA’s future, and let’s seek leaders who reflect 1 Corinthians 14:33’s God of peace, not disorder.
FAQ: Addressing Common Questions
- Why is their rhetoric unbiblical? Owens and Greene distort scripture to vilify opponents, ignoring calls for love and truth (John 13:34, Ephesians 4:15).
- Can Christians support MAGA? Yes, but only if it prioritizes biblical values over grift and division, as 1 John 4:1 urges discernment.
